American Idol '08

***Susan*** · 03-04-2008, 08:26 PM

Am watching it now, I definitely do not think Danny is even close to being the best (David is imo), but....you gotta love his flippant attitude! He puts Simon in his place and I think even Simon enjoys it.

K@t · 03-04-2008, 08:32 PM

I totally love Danny, he is funny. My secret crush is on Jason Castro though. I dunno what it is about that dude but ohhh momma

. And ohh yeah...his singging isn't bad either. I don't care much for Luke, but I hope David and Michael make it farther in the competition. I like the rocker boys. I can't say I care much for any of the girls, but I guess I may be a bit bias.

skyeblu79 · 03-04-2008, 09:17 PM

Tonight David Cook was definitely my fav. I really didn't notice him until tonight. At least not in a good way. David Archuleta is still my all around fav though. I didn't like his performance that much tonight, but I still really like him.

***Susan*** · 03-04-2008, 09:20 PM

I can't say I found any of them to be really bad this week. The first guy wasn't overly exciting though. But, they were definitely better than last week. The girls have a tough act to follow tomorrow night.

travelgirl · 03-05-2008, 12:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by K@t

I totally love Danny, he is funny. My secret crush is on Jason Castro though. I dunno what it is about that dude but ohhh momma

. And ohh yeah...his singging isn't bad either. I don't care much for Luke, but I hope David and Michael make it farther in the competition. I like the rocker boys. I can't say I care much for any of the girls, but I guess I may be a bit bias.

Jason Castro is the one with dreds, right? He's not the best in the competition, but he does have these dreamy blue eyes with those long eyelashes, and he just seems so innocent. He really is adorable.

I haven't watched tonight's yet. We'll watch the boys tomorrow night while the girls are performing, and then watch the girls afterwards. We hate commercials, so we record whenever possible and fast forward through them.

renewedhope · 03-05-2008, 12:31 AM

I really like Jason Castro too. He does look a little like he should be singing on a kid's show, but he is soo adorable. He has a really pretty voice as well. And David Archaletto, well, he is a child prodigy or something. I thought the guys did really well tonight.

gometros · 03-05-2008, 01:50 PM

While you gals are all drooling over Jason and Danny, do you mind if I hold out hope that Brooke leaves her husband?

cowboysfan · 03-05-2008, 02:00 PM

ABSOLUTELY!!!! The guys are totally awesome. Luke's was kind of so so, & Chikezies (sp???) was so so, but the rest of them knocked it out I thought. Especially David Castro!!!! He was the best of the night in my opinion. That version of that song should be redone with him singing it, it would be a major hit all over again. I know I'd buy it just for that song. He's soooo adorable too. Michael is my all around fav though & David Archuletto. That kid is a gift to the music world no doubt!!! And about the sweetest boy I've ever seen!!!!!! A guy is going to win this competition this season, the girls may as well go ahead & get over it.

cowboysfan · 03-05-2008, 02:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gometros

While you gals are all drooling over Jason and Danny, do you mind if I hold out hope that Brooke leaves her husband?

You go ahead, & I'll keep hoping that Michael leaves his wife!!!! HA!!!!

**FairyFacade** · 03-05-2008, 02:23 PM

Danny is gay.....last night is the first night that I thought he sounded good, I thought last night he did AWESOME. I was surprised simon said he 'hated' it.

Jason is a hottie! I loved him singing Hallelujah last night.
And the guy before him, I don't remember his name.. the judges said he could make a single of it.. and I 100% agree, I rewound it on tivo a few times to listen to it.

cowboysfan · 03-05-2008, 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FairyFacade

Danny is gay.....last night is the first night that I thought he sounded good, I thought last night he did AWESOME. I was surprised simon said he 'hated' it.

Jason is a hottie! I loved him singing Hallelujah last night.
And the guy before him, I don't remember his name.. the judges said he could make a single of it.. and I 100% agree, I rewound it on tivo a few times to listen to it.

Danny is so gay....but he's hilarious. I just love his attitude with Simon. It's too funny sometimes. But unlike most people....I love Simon. He cracks me up, and because he's brutally honest at times, some can't take him. The guy before him who sang "Hello" by Lionel Ritchie is David Castro. He is sooooooooooo freakin' good & a hottie. Too cute!!!! I just love the way he performs...Him & Michael both. But I think Castro was the best last night. Those girls better bring it on tonight.

**FairyFacade** · 03-05-2008, 04:33 PM

Well I went and looked it up, it was David Cook.. Jason is Castro.. Right?

Anyway, I watched the video again on Youtube mwhahaha.. MMMM.
I read the comments, it ends up he did NOT come up with the twist on the song. MY FAVORITE BAND OF ALL TIMES DID!! What?! How did I miss this?!

So I looked up Incubus (melt melt melt, ooze, melt)'s cover of Hello. Wowse. Brandon Boyde is just orgasm in leather pants. Anyway, Incubus' cover of Hello was how David Cook did it. Still impressed with his singing ability, but not as impressed with the unique take on the song.

The 17 year old kid, forget his name now.. I almost cried when he sang Imagine, and no doubt he's good.. but last night he didn't get my attention, I thought it was pretty boring.

Oh, and I like all of the judges. I don't think Simon would be doing the artists any justice if he didn't say it 'how it is'. They need the feedback to get better. Sometimes people take it the wrong way, but it shouldn't be personal for them.. it's like having a job, and being told the best way to do the job.
Paula is nice and sweet, but has her feedback ever told them something to help them improve themselves?

cowboysfan · 03-05-2008, 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FairyFacade

Well I went and looked it up, it was David Cook.. Jason is Castro.. Right?

Anyway, I watched the video again on Youtube mwhahaha.. MMMM.
I read the comments, it ends up he did NOT come up with the twist on the song. MY FAVORITE BAND OF ALL TIMES DID!! What?! How did I miss this?!

So I looked up Incubus (melt melt melt, ooze, melt)'s cover of Hello. Wowse. Brandon Boyde is just orgasm in leather pants. Anyway, Incubus' cover of Hello was how David Cook did it. Still impressed with his singing ability, but not as impressed with the unique take on the song.

The 17 year old kid, forget his name now.. I almost cried when he sang Imagine, and no doubt he's good.. but last night he didn't get my attention, I thought it was pretty boring.

Oh, and I like all of the judges. I don't think Simon would be doing the artists any justice if he didn't say it 'how it is'. They need the feedback to get better. Sometimes people take it the wrong way, but it shouldn't be personal for them.. it's like having a job, and being told the best way to do the job.
Paula is nice and sweet, but has her feedback ever told them something to help them improve themselves?

You are right...my bad! Had the names totally mixed up.

cowboysfan · 03-05-2008, 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FairyFacade

Well I went and looked it up, it was David Cook.. Jason is Castro.. Right?

Anyway, I watched the video again on Youtube mwhahaha.. MMMM.
I read the comments, it ends up he did NOT come up with the twist on the song. MY FAVORITE BAND OF ALL TIMES DID!! What?! How did I miss this?!

So I looked up Incubus (melt melt melt, ooze, melt)'s cover of Hello. Wowse. Brandon Boyde is just orgasm in leather pants. Anyway, Incubus' cover of Hello was how David Cook did it. Still impressed with his singing ability, but not as impressed with the unique take on the song.

The 17 year old kid, forget his name now.. I almost cried when he sang Imagine, and no doubt he's good.. but last night he didn't get my attention, I thought it was pretty boring.

Oh, and I like all of the judges. I don't think Simon would be doing the artists any justice if he didn't say it 'how it is'. They need the feedback to get better. Sometimes people take it the wrong way, but it shouldn't be personal for them.. it's like having a job, and being told the best way to do the job.
Paula is nice and sweet, but has her feedback ever told them something to help them improve themselves?

And I did cry when David Archuletto sang "Imagine" For a kid to take on a John Lennon song is beyond brave. And he did it so well. Yeah I like all the judges too. But Randy & Simon crack me up all the time. But that's interesting to know somebody else had done that version because I'd never heard it done like that before. Really cool! And David Cook is soooo hot. My daughter loooooves him to death.

BJean · 03-05-2008, 05:44 PM

Who's gonna go tonight?