http://www.lapbandtalk.com/images/smilies/sleep.gif Hi Fellow Utah Bandsters!
I met with both Dr.'s McKeen and Alldredge and attended both of their seminars. Although I felt that Dr. McKeen was really personable, in the end, I decided to use Dr. Alldredge. I haven't regretted it yet, however, I am still a newbie. (Banded May 12)
Here's why I made my decision:
The published studies indicate that some of the key criteria to keeping complications down and success up include:
A local Dr. with a local practice who has made the commitment to being continuously available for long term follow up care. Dr. McKeen is not local whereas Dr. Alldredge has a very permanent staff and two local facilities, along with well developed programmatic systems to keep you looked after. He has planned periodic follow up groups, a training room, a dietician, and as far as I can tell, about 3-5 permanent, local staff. This makes it very easy to obtain follow up care.
At least 100 LAP-BAND
® surgeries to be considered an expert, and also to minimize the number of complications. Dr.'s McKeen and Dr. Alldredge both come in very close to 200, as I recall.
The more bands a hospital does, the higher the likelihood of avoiding complications. The study suggested 100 as a minimum. Dr. McKeen recently changed from Cottonwood to Provo. As I recall, his office indicated he had done around 12 (my best recollection) when I met with him late April/early May 2005. Conversely, Dr. McKeen uses both a hospital for high risk cases and a surgery center for low risk cases. As I recall, he had done about 100 in each of those two locations himself, plus his partner, apparently had done about 135-150 overall, spread between those two locations.
So for the above reasons - durability, availability and support of the practice;
Experience of the medical center, and similar experience of the Dr., I decided on Alldredge.
Price-wise, they are within $500 of each other in initial costs, but Alldredge's first year of follow up is included, whereas, as I recall, McKeen's is not. This means TCO (Total Cost of Ownership) in my estimation, is lower with Alldredge. That notwithstanding, safety and efficacy has got to overrule anything on cost, as we all have but one body.
Take care, good luck!