help me narrow down mexico surgeon choice

jkpenny376

I respect your opinion, but I believe you have blown this way out of proportion

I don't care about anything negative said about Dr. Rodriguez or any other doctor.

What I specifically asked for is documented proof about Wasa claiming that he had one of the highest erosion rates in the industry. I specifically asked her to send it to me or to post it on this forum to give it validity. If it's accurate information, then please by all means post it!

It's very simple. Sorry you don't see that, but I've actually enjoyed "chatting" with other bandsters about this issue. Because it's good to see that just because someone makes a claim, doesn't make it true or fact, on either side.

Good convos.....

Thanks Cosmos...you Da Man...

thanks Cosmo .
Sorry If i flipped a bit . That just Hit the WRONG Nerve !!!

I got some information today about a doctor that I could NEVER tell anyone where i got it from . the person would lose their job !!!
did it EVER Cross your mind that people get info from people about doctors that could jeopardize their jobs therefore someone is not going to go Publish it or Sing it from message boards ? Yet people relay info to others to make sure others get SAFE Surgeries ??
MAYBE just MAYBE that would be the case ? But would that be sufficient ?
Probably not ! !!!

Wow... that's kind of out there

And non relevant IMO

No it isn't out there...it's a point of view...I completely see it's relivance.

?? I dont see how its not relevant ?
And no its not out there.
People who work certain places cant make it known that they tell certain things , they can lose their jobs .
But people do tell certain things because if people are doing things that are dangerous to peoples lives they tell so others do not go places .
THAT IS RELEVANT !!!

It's not relevant because if you're claiming that a surgeon has the highest erosion rate in the industry, then just supply the documentation that supports the claim. It would be public knowledge and so I don't see how someone would get fired for posting documentation that is available for anyone?

This whole post has taken so many turns, I would rather I just stick to the question I raised which is to please provide me with documented proof or post it here for everyone to see. Very simple really

Im TRYING To tell you why just POSSIBLY ( I am not speaking for WASA ) But WHY Possibly someone CANT tell you where they got the info .
I dont think it would matter anyway .
talk about

I think he just needs to hit that horse a little harder.

She claimed she got the information from Dr. Rod, which is strange anyway. She doesn't have documented proof yet still makes the claim.

I posted a long time ago about beating the dead horse, I see you're willing to help make sure there's no life left at all

Like I said im not sure how much MORE PROOF you want than that .
But anyone could find a problem w/ any info someone gave them if you did not agree w/ it . So keep on beating that horse tell its dead and gone ..
It wont matter what is said , it wont be satisfying !!

Maybe a bigger stick !!!!

Mindy

Mindy,

If responding to posts from you and others is beating a dead horse than so be it.

My original post was a simple question. You keep posting various things about (sometimes) my original post so I keep responding.

So I'm beating the dead horse? I'm just responding to posts.

If you want me to quit posting then use your moderator power or just quit responding to my posts so there won't be anything for me to respond to you about.

I personally enjoy chatting with everyone on here, even you. I think it's very interesting how people mis the meaning of posts and or misinterpret things written and have different views about things.

I dont use moderator "Powers" for anything unless someone is doing hard
And you hit the nail on the head, its just that people have different VIEWS it has nothing to do w/ misinterpreting things. they have different views and opinions. It does not mean someone's is RIGHT or WRONG . But they are OPINIONS or VIEWS . I am not angry , pissy ,ect. I am simply trying to point out that info is given to people in different ways. And your wrong in one aspect. In the US info that happens in hospitals , specific patient info is NOT Public info its Private and for anyone to give it out is a violation of HIPPA . So If someone who works in a hospital says " Dont go to Dr So and so they did this to a patient and they died or this happened and ect.." THAT is a violation of HIPPA and someone could get fired for it .
So people risk their jobs by staing certain things about docs . what happens in OR's ect. Its NOT ALL public info . I am simply trying to give different reasons why someone might not give out "sources" of info .
that's all


Mindy

I totally understand about HIPPA. I work in the medical field.

But I also know that we report certain things that happen to our patients to various government agencies, we are required to do so. This information is then made public so that if you wanted to check out a doctor, you could look up the information. It's kind of like a Better Business Bureau. No one could get fired for sharing this information because it's public record.

I agree with you about if it's your opinion, then post that it's your opinion. My beef was that this was being posted as fact, and it was simply just her opinion.

If it's fact, then it's easily backed up and would be beneficial to post it for patients that are researching Lap Band Surgeons. If it's an opinion, then it just scares people unnecessarily.

I think you and I are basically saying the same thing, but just going the long way around.