I did not start out in the 3's, but I know of many banded people who did. From my understanding, the band can work as many miracles as RNY, it just takes longer.

When I was inquiring about WLS, I asked my doctor if Bands were more appropriate for people with less weight to lose. The majority of doctors I met with stated that both surgeries (LAP-BAND® /RNY) could achieve the same results long term-bandsters just take longer to get there.

One doctor explained to me that while RNY patients lost weight quicker in the beginning, they often begin to regain some of their weight and stretch their pouch. LAP-BAND®'s on the other hand, experience more of a long-term gradual weight loss. The moral of the doctor's story was that 5 years out from surgery, LAP-BAND® and bypass patients have almost identical weight loss results.

May I also suggest that much of your success with the band is linked to the doctor you choose. He/she must have a strong understanding of how to help you post surgically. Certain doctor's have considerably higher success rates with banded patients than others.

If you are able to come to the NY area, may I suggest you get in contact with Dr. Fielding and Dr. Ren of NYU Medical Center's Bariatric Program. Dr. Fielding has the LAP-BAND® himself, so he really, truly understands the key components to weight loss with a band. He and Dr. Ren are also considered among the top doctors in the world for the LAP-BAND®.

GOOD LUCK!!!!

__________________